If Hollywood ever decides to give us the Spice Girls biopic we actually deserve, the casting would make or break the entire project.

This wouldn’t be a campy throwback or a cheesy nostalgia grab — it would need to feel modern, emotional, and culturally sharp, while still honoring the individuality that made the Spice Girls iconic in the first place.

Each member had a clearly defined persona, and today’s casting should reflect that same level of star power, style, and distinct energy. Here’s the dream cast that would absolutely eat.

Victoria Beckham (Posh Spice)
Suggested casting: Jenna Ortega or Olivia Rodrigo

Posh Spice has always been about restraint, attitude, and quiet dominance. She’s not loud — she’s controlled, fashion-forward, and effortlessly intimidating. Jenna Ortega brings a cool, serious presence that would translate beautifully to Victoria’s composed confidence, especially in more dramatic scenes. Olivia Rodrigo, on the other hand, offers a softer but still emotionally complex take, with a natural ability to convey vulnerability beneath a polished exterior. Either choice would modernize Posh without flattening her mystique.

Mel B (Scary Spice)
Suggested casting: Yara Shahidi or Zendaya

Scary Spice is fearless, outspoken, magnetic, and completely unapologetic. Yara Shahidi has the intelligence, charisma, and expressive range to capture Mel B’s bold personality while grounding her in emotional realism. Zendaya, meanwhile, is a proven chameleon. She has the confidence, physicality, and star power to embody Scary Spice’s intensity while still commanding every scene she’s in. This role needs presence — both actresses deliver it effortlessly.

Melanie C (Sporty Spice)
Suggested casting: Addison Rae or Millie Bobby Brown

Sporty Spice is driven, athletic, and emotionally raw in a way that often gets overlooked. Addison Rae makes sense here because of her physicality, dance background, and growing comfort on screen — she could bring a modern, pop-forward interpretation to the role. Millie Bobby Brown, however, would lean more dramatic, capturing Melanie C’s internal struggles, ambition, and resilience. Either route works depending on whether the film skews lighter or more emotionally grounded.

Geri Halliwell (Ginger Spice)
Suggested casting: Sadie Sink or Madelaine Petsch

Ginger Spice is the heart, fire, and rebellious spirit of the group. Sadie Sink has the emotional depth and intensity to portray Geri’s ambition, vulnerability, and eventual departure from the group in a way that would feel powerful rather than sensationalized. Madelaine Petsch brings a more theatrical, high-energy presence that aligns with Ginger’s boldness and larger-than-life persona. Both actresses understand how to balance confidence with emotional stakes.

Emma Bunton (Baby Spice)
Suggested casting: Sabrina Carpenter or Loren Gray

Baby Spice is sweet, charming, and deceptively influential. Sabrina Carpenter would be a standout choice thanks to her comedic timing, vocal ability, and ability to play into innocence without making it feel one-dimensional. Loren Gray also fits naturally here, especially with her pop background and soft, bubbly screen presence. Baby Spice isn’t just cute — she’s iconic — and this role needs someone who can pull that off without irony.

Why this cast works

This lineup reflects what made the Spice Girls powerful in the first place: individuality. Each actress brings a distinct energy, existing fanbase, and modern relevance, which is exactly what a successful biopic needs in today’s culture. This wouldn’t just be a movie for longtime fans — it would introduce the Spice Girls to an entirely new generation.

If Hollywood is serious about reviving iconic girl groups the right way, this is the cast that would make a Spice Girls biopic unforgettable.